The right call

Janet Ecker

Give the Ontario government credit for this one, keeping schools open but delaying the regularly scheduled spring break was the right call.

The government is clearly in the classic situation of “damned if you do and damned if you don’t.” Keep schools open or closed?  Cancel spring break or let it proceed as usual?  No matter what they do, they get roundly criticized.

Adding to the problem is that this is a delicate time with the pandemic.  While the overall number of cases is starting to decline, the number of cases caused by the new, more transmissible strains of COVID are increasing.  The government is anxious not to replicate what happened over the Christmas holidays when cases amongst children at home, celebrating with family and relatives, increased dramatically.

Allowing the March break to go ahead as originally planned could be just what the virus needs to give it another boost. Thus, a decision to cancel could have been justified by the government claiming, as it so often does, that they were just following the science.

But cancelling would bring its own challenges. Parents, teachers and kids could all use a break at some point.  The on-again, off-again nature of this year’s school calendar has not been easy nor is delivering, supervising or receiving virtual education at home.

And then of course, teacher union leaders, with their usual tin ear when it comes to these things, yelled loudly that the break had to go ahead.  Fresh off their two- week break over the Christmas holidays and this month’s Family Day long weekend they were quick to claim the need for additional time-off.

By now they should know not to expect support from the many nurses, doctors and essential front-line workers who have been working literally 24-7 in many instances; not to mention the many thousands of Ontarians who would give their eyeteeth to have any job at all given the economic devastation of so many businesses.

But still, the government was reluctant to pick a fight with the unions at this point.

It should also be noted that at least our front-line teachers have shown up for work whether in real or virtual classrooms, unlike teachers in many U.S. cities who have actually gone out on strike when they didn’t agree with decisions to re-open schools.

So what to do? Wisely, Education Minister Stephen Lecce took a page from the legendary King Solomon’s book of wisdom and decided to delay spring break until later in April when hopefully, progress against the virus coupled with more vaccinations might reduce the risk.

It was the right call.  Everyone gets their anticipated break, but the risks will be better managed by a delay.

Anxious parents can take comfort from the fact that keeping schools open with appropriate precautions is safe, as many countries can confirm given their experience over the last year.

In addition, the Minister has invested over $1.6 billion to make them even safer by hiring over 3,000 more teachers and 1,400 more custodians, by upgrading and improving air filtrations systems and by providing 4,000 rapid diagnostic tests to better screen students or teachers with symptoms.

The research is pretty clear – students are better off in school.  A critical success factor in a child’s education is how much face-time that child can have with a teacher, not to mention the added mental and social benefits.

The government’s handling of the pandemic can be criticized for many things.  But delaying spring break and keeping schools open is not one of them.

Your donations help us continue to deliver the news and commentary you want to read. Please consider donating today.

Donate Today


  • Politics

  • Sports

  • Business