Carney’s immigration scam

Catherine Swift
· 3 min read

Prime Minister Mark Carney’s reputation for mendacity got another boost in the recent federal budget, which put such a spin on how many permanent residents were going to be brought into Canada for the next few years that it was clearly meant to mislead Canadians by implying there were fewer people entering Canada than would actually be the case. As public opinion polls show that the Liberals’ chaotic immigration policy for the last 11 years has actually turned Canadians negative on immigration after decades of positive opinion, Carney and his colleagues know this is a sensitive issue. Instead of heeding Canadians’ concerns and bringing down immigration numbers, the Liberals instead chose to lie about the very large number of permanent residents and new Canadians they are bringing to Canada. 

Although the number 380,000 new permanent residents in 2027 was highlighted in the budget – and this would still be high relative to historical levels of about 250,000 immigrants annually – the real number turns out to be closer to 700,000 once other immigrations streams are factored in, such as making the 200,000 temporary residents currently in Canada into permanent residents. On top of that, the Liberals plan to have another 380,000 temporary residents enter in 2027, 2028 and 2029, and the majority of these would likely become permanent if past patterns were repeated. 

Needless to say, these are drastically high levels that Canadian infrastructure cannot support. Opposition has grown to immigration as Canadians experience a crisis in social services – notably healthcare – as these services are not able to sustain such a large increase in demand. Out of control immigration has also caused housing shortages as the housing market also cannot keep up with the needs of so many new Canadians. The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation has forecast a reduction in housing starts for the next couple of years. When first elected, Carney promised to build 500,000 new homes annually, which is roughly double what is accomplished in an average year. Recently, the Liberals have quietly dropped that promise as it has been proven to be ridiculous and dishonest. 

A recent public opinion poll by Nanos found that just over 52 per cent of respondents wanted to reduce the number of both permanent and temporary residents coming into Canada. The survey also found a majority of those surveyed believe that immigration has changed Canada in ways they don’t like. In previous surveys, concerns over excessive immigration had moderated a bit, likely because enough Canadians actually believed Carney when he said he was reducing overall numbers. Although he did bring down some of the numbers slightly, notably for student visas and temporary foreign workers, overall levels remain much above historical averages and will only worsen existing problems with integrating so many new entrants into Canada in such a short time. 

The Bank of Canada and other economic forecasters expect only sluggish economic growth for Canada over the next couple of years. Unemployment is already high, especially for younger workers, and hundreds of thousands of new immigrants will also worsen the situation. What Carney is doing and trying to delude Canadians about by fudging the numbers is profoundly unfair to people currently in Canada as well as newcomers who will find it very difficult to find work or a place to live. 

Some analysts believe that the Liberals are going to such extremes with immigration so they can bring in more taxpayers to bring down our massive deficits and debt. However, the data consistently show that new entrants typically are dependent on government support for their first few years in Canada so a beneficial impact on national finances is unrealistic. The immigration numbers outlined in the budget represent a reckless and dangerous threat to Canada and should be revised downward significantly.

This bald-faced lie by Carney about immigration is on top of his pretense to be shocked by the recent Stellantis’ announcement they were laying off workers when as it turns out Carney, Industry Minister Mélanie Jolie and others had several meetings with Stellantis executives on this very topic over the past few months. Other whoppers he was caught trying to pull off include his lie that Trump hadn’t gotten the better of him over financing the Gordie Howe bridge, his housing numbers that were much overblown, that Canada now enjoys the best affordability in 10 years and others about Canada’s fiscal strength and debt management. Given Carney’s practice of constant dishonesty on so many issues, it is amazing that anyone believes anything he says. 

How many more lies will Carney feel entitled to tell Canadians before Liberal supporters finally realize they are being scammed by the guy who was sold as the solution to all of Canada’s problems? If Canada does indeed take on all of the immigrants included in the federal budget, we may be finding out very soon.

Catherine Swift
Columnist

Catherine Swift was President of the Coalition of Concerned Manufacturers &  Businesses Canada from 2022 to 2026. She was previously President of Working Canadians from 2015-2021 & President & CEO of the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) from 1995-2014. She was Chief Economist of the CFIB from 1987-1995, Senior Economist with TD Bank from 1983-1987 & held several positions with the federal government from 1976-1983.

She has published numerous articles in journals, magazines & other media on issues such as free trade, finance, entrepreneurship & women business owners. Ms. Swift is a past President of the Empire Club of Canada, a former Director of the CD Howe Institute, the Canadian Youth Business Foundation, SOS Children’s Villages, past President of the International Small Business Congress and current Director of the Fraser Institute. She was cited in 2003 & 2012 as one of the most powerful women in Canada by the Women’s Executive Network & is a recipient of the Queen’s Silver & Gold Jubilee medals.

She has an Honours BA and MA in Economics.

More from Catherine Swift →