DEI dies in Alberta
Hiring based on factors other than merit also leads to poorer performance in businesses and government, and research has shown it imposes increased costs as well.
Striking a blow for sanity and common sense, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith banned the practice of DEI (diversity, equity and inclusion) hiring in the Alberta public sector earlier this week. Following DEI principles basically means hiring on the basis of criteria such as skin colour, gender, disability, sexual orientation, being an underrepresented group in a particular workplace and possibly other characteristics that have absolutely nothing to do with merit. Among other things, it has led to perverse outcomes such as some job opportunities being closed off to white heterosexual men, limited to certain racial backgrounds or rigid quotas for hiring from particular groups. Hiring based on factors other than merit also leads to poorer performance in businesses and government, and research has shown it imposes increased costs as well.
The origin of the DEI type of approach was well-intentioned, as are many of these initiatives at the beginning. Many decades ago, employment equity and affirmative action policies were introduced, primarily focussed on promoting the hiring of women and racial minorities. These policies got more rigid over time, leading to quotas and a diminished importance of merit in hiring decisions. Pay equity took things a step further, trying to correct gender-based differences in various occupations by attempting to compare jobs that were female-dominated – teachers, for example – to occupations that were deemed to be of similar skill levels but dominated by men. This led to some ridiculous outcomes such as the pay of nurses (female-dominated) being compared to pastry chefs (male-dominated). This was actually the policy in Ontario at one time.
DEI took things to a whole new level of rigidity and absurdity. A much broader range of characteristics were to be considered – not only gender, race and disabilities but also sexual orientation, religion, older employees etc. DEI also frequently involved actual prohibitions on the hiring of certain categories of individuals, not just favouring one group or another. This is an egregious practice in general, but especially in the context of government employment which is financed by everyone’s taxes yet DEI means certain taxpayer groups are not permitted to apply for government jobs.
Things got increasingly problematic when companies were required to report regularly on their employee complement and how it was composed by gender, race, etc., imposing costly new regulations on business. Companies were sued by some of the DEI subgroups, resulting in court decisions that enshrined DEI principles. Another destructive impact of DEI policies fell on the very groups the policy was supposed to help. Many individuals of various racial groups, disabled, LGBTQ etc. were accused of being “DEI hires” when in fact they obtained the job on merit. As is so often the case with government policies, the people that were supposed to be helped by the policy ended up damaged by it.
"*" indicates required fields
It is no mystery that Smith has little time for woke policies. This past Tuesday, she announced that her government had tabled Bill 33, a justice statutes amendment act, to eliminate DEI policies in the public sector and government agencies. The bill also mandates merit-based hiring in government which includes municipalities, post-secondary institutions and could be extended to organizations that receive government funding. Also included in the Bill is that any mandatory workplace training or education must be “ideologically neutral.”
Smith’s elimination of DEI policies in government also represents a challenge for Alberta’s NDP Opposition, now led by former Calgary mayor Naheed Nenshi. As public opinion polls show that most Albertans oppose DEI, Nenshi will likely have to mute any opposition the NDP has to this bill, despite the fact that the NDP are typically big proponents of these types of policies.
It is likely not a coincidence that Smith is introducing this policy shortly after the referendum on separation that left her supporters who favoured separation very disappointed and disgruntled with Smith’s leadership. Changing the channel to a policy like DEI elimination, which will probably attract close to 100 per cent support among Smith’s United Conservative Party membership, may soften some of the blow of the referendum result for separation supporters.
Smith has been a trailblazer in opposing some of the biggest components of the “woke” agenda. For instance, her government has affirmed that only biological females belong in women’s sports, that biological men should not be housed in women’s prisons, has put an age limitation on transgender-related surgeries and made changes to remove politics from the public school system. All of these moves were based in common sense and had the support of the majority of average Canadians. All indications show that Alberta’s elimination of DEI hiring in government will also meet with majority public approval. Hopefully her leadership will also produce similar changes in other provinces.