Mayoral candidates best suited to protect their towns in pending Niagara governance reform discussions
For years, the provincial government has questioned whether Niagara’s two-tier municipal structure remains efficient and affordable. The debate has intensified as taxpayers have faced substantial increases in regional taxes and service charges over the past four years.
The conversation about municipal reform gained momentum in 2018 when Ontario Premier Doug Ford reduced the size of Toronto City Council despite significant opposition. Since then, the provincial government has repeatedly expressed concerns about the number of elected officials serving within Niagara’s regional and local governments. Niagara’s approximately 500,000 residents are governed by 126 elected officials spread across 12 municipalities and the regional government. By comparison, the single-tier City of Hamilton serves a similar population with one mayor and 15 councillors.
Those concerns led the province to send a governance review commission to Niagara in 2019 to examine possible changes to the region’s structure. The province has also shown a willingness to reconsider regional government elsewhere in Ontario, including taking steps to dissolve Peel Region. These actions have fuelled speculation that Niagara’s current governance model will face significant after the 2026 municipal elections as well.
With governance restructuring, perhaps including amalgamations in some form, hanging over voters heads in every municipality in Niagara – it’s important to try to determine which mayoral candidate is best suited in each municipality to look after his/her towns’ best interests where future governance is concerned.
The Easy Picks
NOTL
Erwin Wiens. Wiens is a NOTL lifer. He is a two-time councillor and Deputy Lord Mayor. He has put in Lord Mayor time the past four years without the concomitant salary. He has cultivated strong relationships with other municipal mayors, regional councillors, the feds and the provincial government. His expert opinion is frequently sought after by agriculture officials. He got massive federal and provincial contributions to the Shaw and to irrigation systems in agriculture in NOTL. He is trusted by both Doug Ford and current Minister of Municipal Affairs Rob Flack. He has been a strong vocal opponent to amalgamation – a leader amongst the 8 small municipalities fending it off. Retired from the Hamilton Police Service – Ford loves the police.
His likely closest opponent is transplant to NOTL Vaughn Goettler who has spent his time in this campaign reminding local organizations that he donated to them. That and dissing the Premier, whom he disparagingly refers to as ‘Dougie’. He’d likely be the irritant that would push Ford over the edge to merging NOTL with other communities. Three-time Liberal candidate, local NOTL lifer Andrea Kaiser, would be less irritating but just as unable to stop amalgamation as would Goettler.
Niagara Falls
Jim Diodati. The most experienced and successful Mayor in the Region. An incomparable bridgebuilder who has been able to charm Liberals (McGuinty, Wynne, Trudeau and Carney) and Tories (Ford, Flack) alike. He brilliantly got Wynne to pay Niagara Falls a larger amount for hosting the OLG in his city and has used that wealth to help keep local taxes lower than surrounding municipalities, fund extra police presence, and pay for the city’s required portion of a new $3.6 billion hospital, MRI machines, doctor recruitment and sports and recreation facilities. Diodati adroitly and almost single-handedly (he had a small assist from the aforementioned Wiens – a colleague on the Niagara Park Commission) got the province to back off its plan to put a giant redundant Ferris wheel in Queen Victoria Park.
"*" indicates required fields
His only close opponent is two-time councillor Lori Lococo. Her lack of charisma, opposition to senior levels of government, career as a naysayer and closeness with the NDP would likely mean she would have little to no influence over future amalgamations or governance reform.
Welland
April Jeffs. Former two-time Mayor of Wainfleet and thus a two-time regional councillor. Adept at municipal politics. Understands very well the relationships between the cities and the region. Works at Brock University, frequently discoursing with provincial ministries. Appointed by Doug Ford to both the Niagara Parks Commission as its Chair and to the Niagara Falls Bridge Commission – she is well liked at Queen’s Park and is best positioned to secure Welland’s future.
St. Catharines
Matt Siscoe. Most experienced candidate in the race. A listened to voice at the Region. A high school teacher and football coach who ran as a candidate for the Tories in 2014. Again, well-liked at Queen’s Park and in Ottawa. A highly regarded municipal leader. Has been the first Mayor in a while to keep local taxes in check while shouldering the burden of regular huge increases from the Region that he must unfairly explain to his own ratepayers.
His mayoral opponents are all political neophytes who have never held public office.
The ones that seem logical
Lincoln
Greg Reimer. Solid businessman. A two-term councillor in Lincoln he served as Deputy Mayor and close confidant to retiring Mayor Sandra Easton. Easton was considered a rock-star by Queen’s Park. It is known they would have liked her to be the next Regional Chair. She was a vocal supporter of the 4-city approach. She would have been in the best position to secure a good future for Lincoln in any new governance structure. Insiders say the Deputy Mayor apple Reimer doesn’t fall far from the tree.
Councillor Adam Russell is not a bad second choice. Solid taxpayer protector – has provincial experience as he has worked with OLG for years.
Port Colborne
Bill Steele. Mayor since 2018. Other candidates are inexperienced or just not right for the job. Steele, like Siscoe, is well regarded in upper levels of government and has already attempted to change up governance by reducing duplication with the region.
Pelham
Marvin Junkin. Two-time mayor. Lots of experience. Common sense farming background. Boldly disrupted previous regime in Pelham and blew doors off a government that needed to go. Well-liked at Queens’ park. Experience and relationships make him most well placed.
Toss ups
Fort Erie
Regional Councillor Tom Insinna, a former RCMP officer and Tory (Ford loves cops!), or very experienced long-time Mayor and lawyer Wayne Redekop. Both have very good credentials and capabilities. Insinna took on Niagara Regional Police over its ever-expanding budget when at the Region. Redekop is a known NDP supporter but has balanced that over the years to be able to manage relationships well with upper levels of government. Toss-up.
Grimsby
Jeff Jordan is seeking re-election. Most experienced. Simon Duong, former chair of Downtown Grimsby Business Improvement Area and owner of the Grimsby Peach Kings junior-C hockey club and Teddy’s Sports Bar, is well-liked and a very pro-business small-c conservative. The experience may be the best shot for Grimsby.
Thorold
Current councillor and former Mayor Henry D’Angela vs. current regional councillor Tim Whalen. Neither has any pull at Queen’s Park, as far as we know. Toss-up.
Wainfleet
The smallest municipality will most assuredly get swallowed up in governance restructuring. Current Mayor Brian Grant vs former Mayor Kevin Gibson. Gibson is a former RCMP officer with 34 years of service. Doug Ford loves cops! Gibson knows municipal government too. Gibson was Wainfleet’s mayor from 2018 to 2022. But his first two budgets raised local taxes 9.7% in 2019 and 9.2% in 2020, which may be why he lost a close race in 2022 to current Mayor Brian Grant. Toss up.
West Lincoln
Cheryl Ganann – acclaimed