Ontario Liberals picked a Trudeau insider. Now Bains has to say what he’d do differently
Navdeep Bains is pitching his Ottawa record as a reason to trust him with Ontario's economy. That record is also a reason to ask hard questions.
Navdeep Bains says the “Ontario Deal” is broken: work hard, earn a decent living, and you should be able to afford a home. Plenty of Ontarians would agree with him. But coming from a man who spent more than five years as Justin Trudeau’s innovation minister, it invites an awkward follow-up. What did the government you helped run get wrong?
Ontario Liberals chose Bains on Saturday. He beat Lee Fairclough on the third ballot with 50.3 per cent, a margin of fewer than 80 points, and takes over a party that has watched Doug Ford win three majorities in a row. Bains has made his federal résumé a big part of his pitch. That’s fair. Voters should judge it by what it produced.
Start with a program he ran himself. The Innovation Superclusters Initiative, now called the Global Innovation Clusters, put federal money behind industry partnerships meant to drive innovation and jobs. In October 2020, while Bains was still minister, the Parliamentary Budget Officer found spending far behind schedule and called it highly unlikely the program would hit Ottawa’s GDP target. Bains pushed back at the time, saying the PBO’s data only ran to March 2020. Since then, the department says the clusters have approved 676 projects with more than $3.39 billion in total investment, about $1.28 billion of it federal. So the program did draw in private money. What it hasn’t shown is how much of that activity would have happened anyway, and what taxpayers got for the difference. Anyone promising to grow Ontario’s economy with public money should be able to answer that.
Then there’s the wider Trudeau record. Ottawa let population growth run well ahead of housing. In 2023, the Bank of Canada said flatly that Canada needed more homes. Ottawa’s own 2024 budget conceded that the jump in temporary residents was a factor in falling GDP per person. That October, the government cut its 2025 permanent resident target from 500,000 to 395,000. The OECD’s 2025 survey of Canada found output per person still below where it was before the pandemic. Headline growth looked fine. Per person it didn’t, and federal policy made a housing shortage worse.
"*" indicates required fields
In fairness to Bains, he left cabinet in January 2021, before the temporary resident surge and before Trudeau reversed course. Those decisions aren’t his. The economic policies he helped shape are, and his judgment now can be measured by how honestly, he talks about what came after. If he thinks Ottawa got population growth wrong, he should say so. Then he should tell us how an Ontario government he leads would make sure communities have the infrastructure to build the housing they need.
His platform promises to make it easier to build homes people can afford and to cut unnecessary taxes, fees, red tape and delays. Fine goals. In Niagara, the test is concrete. A municipality needs water and sewer upgrades before a new subdivision can go ahead. Who pays, and when do shovels go in? His platform talks about highways, transit, schools and hospitals but says nothing about water or sewer. The same goes for his proposed Ontario Jobs Fund. If Queen’s Park hands public money to a company, taxpayers should know what that company promised in return and what happens if it doesn’t deliver. Right now, the platform doesn’t say.
None of this lets Ford off the hook. His record deserves its own scrutiny, which is exactly why the choice of Liberal leader matters. Ontario needs an opposition that can make a believable case for doing things differently. Bains asked Canadians to trust his economic judgment for years in Ottawa. Now he wants Ontario’s trust as the man who’d replace Ford. Before he gets it, he owes voters a straight answer about where the Trudeau government went wrong and what he learned from sitting at that table.