Regional Councillors Seek Local Office Amid Ongoing Debate Over Taxes and Government Reform
As Niagara residents prepare to vote in the municipal elections on October 26, 2026, several sitting members of Niagara Regional Council are seeking new local offices. Their campaigns come at a time when property taxes, government spending, and the future of regional governance have become central issues for voters across the region.
The political context surrounding this election extends far beyond individual candidates. For years, the provincial government has questioned whether Niagara’s two-tier municipal structure remains efficient and affordable. The debate has intensified as taxpayers have faced substantial increases in regional taxes and service charges over the past four years.
The conversation about municipal reform gained momentum in 2018 when Ontario Premier Doug Ford reduced the size of Toronto City Council despite significant opposition. Since then, the provincial government has repeatedly expressed concerns about the number of elected officials serving within Niagara’s regional and local governments. Niagara’s approximately 500,000 residents are governed by 126 elected officials spread across 12 municipalities and the regional government. By comparison, the single-tier City of Hamilton serves a similar population with one mayor and 15 councillors.
Those concerns led the province to send a governance review commission to Niagara in 2019 to examine possible changes to the region’s structure. The province has also shown a willingness to reconsider regional government elsewhere in Ontario, including taking steps to dissolve Peel Region. These actions have fuelled speculation that Niagara’s current governance model could eventually face significant changes as well.
One area drawing scrutiny is taxation. Since 2023, residents throughout Niagara have experienced a series of substantial regional tax increases. The regional property tax levy rose 7.58 per cent in 2023, 7.02 per cent in 2024, 9.6 per cent in 2025, and 6.3 per cent in 2026. Together, these increases represent approximately 24 per cent growth over the current term of council, with an average annual increase of roughly 7.6 per cent.
Water and wastewater rates have increased even more rapidly. Regional rates climbed approximately 7.5 per cent in 2023, 7.95 per cent in 2024, 12.27 per cent in 2025, and 7.42 per cent in 2026. The average annual increase over the period was approximately 8.8 per cent.
Transit is another growing component of regional taxes. Following the consolidation of local transit systems into the Niagara Region Transit Commission, a separate transit levy was added to property tax bills. Transit levy increases have averaged more than six per cent annually.
The Niagara Region’s 2026 budget process led then Regional Chair Bob Gale to tell the province that the process “laid bare the failings of our municipal governance structure” and revealed patterns that “raise serious concerns regarding waste, abuse and a culture of casualness with taxpayer dollars.”
"*" indicates required fields
These increases have placed local municipal politicians in a difficult position. Although city and town councils distribute property tax bills to residents, they are also responsible for collecting the regional share of those taxes. When the provincial property tax component is removed the regional portion accounts for roughly 60 per cent of the average property tax bill and exceeds 70 per cent in some municipalities, including Niagara-on-the-Lake. As a result, many local politicians have argued that taxpayers often blame local councils for increases that originate primarily from decisions made at the regional level.
The issue has become particularly significant because several regional councillors are now seeking election to municipal offices. Voters evaluating those candidates will inevitably be asked to consider their records on taxation, spending, and regional governance.
Among the candidates seeking higher office is Michele Seaborn, who currently serves as a regional councillor for Grimsby and is now running for mayor of that municipality. In Welland, regional councillor Pat Chiocchio is seeking the mayor’s office, while Tim Whalen is campaigning to become mayor of Thorold. Regional councillor Tom Insinna is running for mayor in Fort Erie, and Andrea Kaiser is seeking election as mayor of Niagara-on-the-Lake.
Several current regional councillors are also pursuing local council positions. Wayne Olson is seeking a council seat in Pelham. In Niagara Falls, both Kim Craitor and Joyce Morocco are candidates for city council seats.
Critics, contend that taxpayers have not seen enough effort to reduce costs or improve efficiency at the Region. One example frequently cited involves provincial changes that removed planning responsibilities from the region. The change could have eliminated approximately 60 positions and more than $6 million in salaries, but those employees were reassigned within the Region rather than removed, resulting in no direct taxpayer savings.
As election day approaches, Niagara voters will have an opportunity to weigh these competing arguments. The campaigns of current regional councillors seeking local office are likely to become a focal point in broader discussions about taxation, accountability, and the future of regional government. Whether voters view the last four years as a period of necessary investment or excessive spending may ultimately determine the political fortunes of several candidates across Niagara on October 26.