The Senate races that will decide Trump’s future

What follows is this author's best guess after consulting some of the most objective and informed sources in America.

Dave Redekop
· 5 min read

Whoever wins the Senate races in several competitive contests across America will decide whether U.S. President Donald Trump spends the next two years defending himself against investigations and potential impeachment or serving as Commander-in-Chief. Democrats are very interested in occupying Trump’s time with lawyers, pesky questions from the press about high crimes and misdemeanours and destroying any historical credibility he has left. Winning closely fought races in states Trump won easily in 2024 now seems possible. Blue states Trump lost may offer a glimmer of hope for the GOP as it scrambles to hold on to one house of Congress. Which states look most likely to flip on Nov. 3, and which ones will the GOP hold? What follows is this author’s best guess after consulting some of the most objective and informed sources in America. 

GOP SEATS GONE OR IN PLAY

North Carolina – Former Democratic Governor Roy Cooper will defeat Michael Whatley and replace retiring Republican Senator Thom Tillis. The MAGA crowd drove Tillis out and will now have to deal with Cooper. This will be a net gain for the Democrats. 

Maine – Senator Susan Collins has held this seat for the Republicans since 1996 and hopes to win a sixth term. Troy Jackson remains competitive in many polls, but Collins has always overcome deficits to win comfortably. Her time may be up. Trump’s popularity is in the tank in Maine, and even though Jackson has proven to be a poor candidate with a weird personal life, Collins may struggle to turn out enough voters to overcome Democratic enthusiasm to punish the president. Democratic gain. 

Ohio – Watch this one closely. John Husted, appointed to fill the seat after J.D. Vance ascended to the vice-presidency, has been picking up steam and may pull this out, even after trailing in most polls this fall. His opponent, Sherrod Brown, who just lost his seat in 2024, was a suitable candidate, but well known. That may hurt him in the end. Ohio has been trending red for some time, and an old voice like Brown’s may, ironically, help Republicans in this race. Republican hold. 

Alaska – This high-stakes battleground race has become a neck-and-neck contest between Senator Dan S. Sullivan and his Democratic challenger, Mary Peltola. Adding to the chaos, a name controversy has arisen with another Dan Sullivan getting placed on the ballot. There are four candidates listed, but Republicans contend that the other Dan Sullivan is a “Democratic plant” designed to siphon votes from the incumbent. Courts have resisted forcing the other Sullivan off the ballot but have made the distinction clear by including Senator Sullivan’s name and party as part of his name. Regardless, the race is close, and Peltola, the first Alaska Native to serve in Congress, also defeated Sarah Palin on her way to office in 2022. Too close to call, the Democrats think they may pull this one out. Polymarket odds favour Peltola at 75 per cent. Democratic gain. 

Texas – The Democrats hope to win their first statewide race in Texas since 1994. Democrat James Talarico has led Republican Ken Paxton for most of the fall and appears poised to win if he can withstand Paxton’s late cash infusion from the national party. Talarico’s brand of leftist politics seems ill-suited for Texas, but Paxton has a terrible personal life and was impeached by his Republican peers in 2023 for abuse of office involving a donor, bribery, retaliation against whistleblowers, and obstruction of justice. The Texas House voted 121-23 to press the case to the state Senate, where Paxton was acquitted when the vote fell short of the two-thirds needed to convict. Paxton defeated long-time Senator John Cornyn in the primary, but whether he can defy the odds and overcome his opponent’s lead remains uncertain. Talarico has a 63-65 per cent chance of winning, according to the Polymarket odds. Democratic gain.  

Iowa – The Republicans looked cooked in this race until recent polls showed a tightening of Democratic State Representative Josh Turek’s lead over Congresswoman Ashley Hinson, the Republican candidate. Iowa has become reliably red under Trump, but fuel prices and inflation are causing Hinson major headaches. Another one too close to call but would become a Democratic pickup if Turek can hold his lead. Polymarket odds favour Hinson at 57%.  Republican hold. 

Kansas – How Kansas became a race should concern the GOP. No Democratic Senator has been elected from the Sunflower State since 1932. Regardless, this contest remains close, though Polymarket still favours first-term incumbent Republican Senator Roger Marshall to defeat Adam Hamilton, the senior pastor of a prominent Kansas City megachurch. Republican hold. 

South Carolina – Almost as baffling as Kansas is how South Carolina became a contest. With popular Senator Lindsay Graham’s death and his unknown sister (Darline Graham Nordone) turning her appointment as his replacement into a candidacy, the Democrats saw an opening. Nominating Dr. Annie Andrews, a prominent pediatrician, the Democrats have watched Andrews surge in the polls. Nordone’s clunky campaign has not set voters on fire, and the race has now become a toss-up, though Polymarket odds still favour the incumbent at 80 per cent. Republican hold. 

DEMOCRATIC SEATS IN PLAY

In a year favouring the “out” party, the Democrats still find themselves on the defensive in Minnesota and Michigan. Having nominated two socialist candidates in these Midwestern states, Democrats believed they could use their advantages to retain these open seats. With Amy Klobuchar moving up to run for governor of Minnesota, Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan was blocked from running by natural succession. Instead, she chose to run for the seat Senator Tina Smith was giving up to return to private life. In Michigan, Senator Gary Peters decided to retire. At the time, everyone concluded the Democrats would easily retain the seats. Not so fast. 

Minnesota – Lt. Gov. Flanagan has been tarred by the “Somali scandal,” primarily referring to Feeding Our Future, a massive federal fraud case that stemmed from pandemic-relief funds. Flanagan’s opponent, former FOX Sports NFL sideline reporter Michelle Tefoya, has run a model campaign, turning a romp into a toss-up. Flanagan remains the heavy favourite, but polling suggests the race is close. Democratic hold.  

Michigan – Perhaps the most closely watched race in the union, Democratic nominee Abdul El-Sayed versus Republican Mike Rogers, the Michigan race has national implications. If the first declared Muslim Senator wins in Michigan as a socialist, it will embolden the Democratic Left to push for a presidential candidate who will also espouse redistributionist policies, take a hard line against support for Israel, and return to wide-open immigration policies. Polymarket odds favour El Sayed, but it will be close. If the Republicans gain this seat, they may retain control of the Senate. It could all come down to Michigan. Republican gain. 

These races are so tight they could shift over a few days. With only a short time to Election Day and voters already checking off ballots, decisions are being made in real time. Governors’ races and House contests are also worth noting, but space limits detailed analysis. Watch Florida for an early clue, follow New York’s results if you think any surprises are mounting, and see whether Oregon’s Democratic governor holds on or is shocked by a strong Republican candidate.

Dave Redekop
Columnist

Dave Redekop is a retired elementary resource teacher who worked part-time at the St. Catharines Courthouse as a Registrar until being appointed Executive Director at Redeemer Bible Church in October 2023. He has worked on political campaigns since high school and attended university in South Carolina for five years, earning a Master’s in American History with a specialization in Civil Rights. Dave loves reading biographies.

More from Dave Redekop →