Upheaval in B.C.
It was a rout. Commentators are discussing former BC Premier Eby’s decision to call a snap election as possibly the biggest political error in Canadian history. The outcome of the past weekend’s provincial election in BC could not have even been fathomed a few weeks ago. Although the results are still being finalized, there is no question that the Conservative Party of BC won an overwhelming majority, tossing out the provincial NDP for the first time in just over 9 years. The seat count that appears final at this time is 63 for the Conservatives, 28 for the NDP and 2 for the Green Party.
Many news outlets made a big deal out of saying it was the first Conservative victory in BC in almost a century, but that’s not really true. It may be the first time since 1928 that a party that had “Conservative” in their name was in power, but there have been many free-enterprise, centre-right parties in government in BC over the years. The BC Liberal party, for example, was essentially conservative in nature and often even more conservative in their policy direction than political parties that called themselves conservative in other provinces.
As is often the case, it became clear that the snap election called by NDP leader David Eby when he was barely two years into a four-year mandate was resented by voters. The fact that there was also a municipal election underway, the date of which had been known for years, also annoyed BC voters who did not appreciate two elections coming so close together and Eby’s gall in his last-minute planning of the provincial election on almost the exact same date as the municipal one.
Another interesting element of this election was how Eby conducted his campaign. He ran very heavily on the MAGA theme, and how the Conservatives were far-right and dangerous for the province. This is pretty much the same template that has been used by the federal Liberals and other Premiers – notably Ontario’s Doug Ford. Yet that approach, which has been successful in the past, did not resonate with BC voters. Maybe Canadians are starting to smarten up and realize that our own governments are doing more damage to our country than Trump, and that most of Canada’s most serious problems predate Trump and his tariffs by several years.
It was not surprising that Eby chose to run on an anti-MAGA platform, as he certainly couldn’t run on his abysmal record. Eby’s government had been on a spend-a-thon for years after inheriting a healthy surplus, drastically increasing the province’s deficit and debt with nothing to show for it except an even more bloated government sector and deteriorating public services. One of the most problematic aspects of Eby’s tenure was the secretive deals he made with various First Nations groups on a number of land claims issues. The fact that Eby went behind pretty much everyone’s backs, including some of his own colleagues, to agree to land claims that threatened the ownership of private property, will have repercussions across Canada in terms of the settling of private property rights.
It remains to be seen what this very abrupt change in government in the province will actually mean in terms of policies pursued. The BC Conservatives’ getting their act together so quickly was impressive after the disarray they experienced under the brief leadership of Kerry-Lynne Findlay. The interim leader that took over from Findlay just two days before the election was called, Lorne Doerkson, has an interesting and varied background. He was a rodeo rider in his younger days, a publisher of community newspapers for 20 years, then entered politics in 2020 and won a seat as a BC Liberal. He later joined John Rustad’s Conservative caucus. He has kept a low-key profile since, ably performing the roles of deputy house leader and assistant deputy speaker for the Conservatives. Doerkson’s personality has often been referred to as that of a “favourite uncle”, which undoubtedly appealed to BC voters after the turbulence and drama of Eby’s tenure.
"*" indicates required fields
As far as policies the Conservatives will implement, they discussed decreasing taxes and speeding up approvals of various major projects, issues that badly need attention everywhere in Canada. Doerkson has pledged to repeal the damaging Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (DRIPA), which has been so controversial in calling into question private property rights. The new Conservative government will surely have lots of challenges on its hands with very constrained public finances, investment declines, a sluggish economy and major Indigenous land claim disputes.
Perhaps the most ironic element of this whole BC situation is that Eby clearly believed his Conservative opponents were in disarray – and it did look that way for a while – and thought to capitalize on it by quickly calling a snap election. Most decent politicians, even when they see that their opponents are in a difficult situation and without a leader, typically have the decency to at least wait until things settle somewhat for their opposition before doing something like calling a snap election. Eby had no such decency, and his naked opportunism was not appreciated by the electorate. It’s nice to see that the BC voter base understood how shamefully Eby was behaving. Let’s hope that’s contagious to other parts of Canada, where many other smug, complacent and underperforming governments richly deserve a wake-up call.