Mark Carney’s backroom EU deals sure to cost Canadians

Chris George
· 7 min read

Arriving in Montreal on Wednesday night, the President of the European Commission, Ursula Gertrud von der Leyen, posted on social media, “Rarely have I looked forward to a Summit this much. An ocean separates Europe and Canada. Yet we have never felt closer. We have a new ambition: bringing Canada closer to us than ever before, as Associate Member of the EU… Montreal, we’re about to write a new chapter in our shared history.” Von der Leyen joins her political ally Prime Minister Mark Carney to lead the 21st Canada-EU summit, a meeting that is to consummate the backroom deals designed to tie Canada into the political agendas of the EU and its bureaucracy in Brussels, Belgium.

The Canadian prime minister celebrated von der Leyen’s arrival in a public statement: “For the past year and a half, Canada and the European Union have been working with speed and determination to forge an ambitious new partnership.” Indeed, Carney is anxious to tighten the knot between Canada and the EU on everything from trade and energy to defence spending and programmable digital currency. He is intently forging ahead with his plans. And, he is doing so regardless of the suspect economic and social consequences for the country, a stinging rebuke this week by EU members, and the fact that the prime minister has not presented any details of his deals with von der Leyen to the Canadian public, nor debated them in the Canadian Parliament.   

The Canada-EU partnership was being contrived since Carney first took office. In early September, the public initially learned of it in the U.S. newspaper The Wall Street Journal, “Mark Carney’s Audacious Bid to Make Canada an ‘Associate Member’ of the EU” and Canadians first heard their prime minister speak about his EU plans when he addressed the European Parliament in Strasbourg, France. At that time, Carney stated, “The world is more dangerous and divided. In response, Canada and the European Union are building on each other’s strengths – deliberately, systematically, and rapidly – to form a new, ambitious alliance.” 

Since, Carney has issued multiple press releases describing the quid pro quo: “The EU brings market power, research depth, and manufacturing strength. Canada brings abundant energy, critical minerals, world-class capabilities in space, artificial intelligence (AI), and quantum, and one of the world’s strongest banking systems.” Carney has stated he expects the new partnership will increase the $178 billion of trade with the Europeans and build on the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) signed with the EU in 2017 (even though 10 of 27 European countries have refused to ratify that agreement almost a decade later). 

Carney has staked a great deal of political capital on the Canada-EU deals; since becoming prime minister, it has been recorded that he has spent more days with political leaders in Europe (50) than he has spent with Canadian MPs in the House of Commons (36). However, his trysts with von der Leyen have been met with resistance now that elected members in Europe and Canada – and Canadians – have learned how involved the new partnership is. 

Canadians are looking for details about the proposal to become “an associate member state of the EU,” an arrangement that was advanced by the prime minister’s office, as admitted by a senior Canadian trade official. Montreal’s Summit will prove to be the first time the prime minister has shared any details with Canadians – and that is disconcerting given foreign affairs and trade agreements usually are discussed publicly and debated in Parliament before being signed.   

In late September the international news organization Politico first reported on a leaked nine-page draft agreement between Canada and the EU, “a deeper and more integrated relationship” on trade, energy, digital ID technologies and AI, and security. The draft document was also reported to identify the Canada-EU Green Alliance as “our compass” which would establish shared 2050 climate goals and a regime of carbon pricing and industrial decarbonization. That revelation set off alarm bells for Tammy Nemeth, a UK-based energy analyst and consultant, who subsequently wrote a strong warning about the Canada-EU agreement in the Western Standard. In her column “Ottawa’s leaked EU deal strangles Alberta’s resources and sovereignty with regulations,” Nemeth tells of the Carney braintrust “quietly bargaining away provincial resource rights in backroom deals with Brussels.” In assessing the agreement, she concludes the Alberta oil and gas sector would be crippled by net zero targets, the Brussels bureaucracy and its regulations: 

“These costs would leave Canadian companies, at best, competitive with European firms already carrying the same burdens, but priced out of the North American market where American producers face neither the EU rulebook nor a matching Canadian version. The proposal risks turning Canada into a regulatory island inside North America, cut off from the huge market next door.”

In her State of the Union speech to the EU Parliament, von der Leyen shared her objective, “We want to bring the relationship with Canada to the highest level possible.” This has proved to be as problematic for European politicians as it has been for Canadians. The surprising announcement that Canada would become the EU’s first “associate member” caused a furor, so much so that this week, on the eve of the Montreal Summit where such an agreement was to have been signed, Germany, Italy, France, and Greece objected to the draft Canada-EU declaration and has cancelled out any idea of a formally recognized associate membership. At question was: Where exactly would Canada fit within the Union’s four freedoms of movement – goods, services, capital and people – in the European single market “seamless, borderless, and effectively invisible”? With the rebuke, the partnership documents were hastily rewritten on Wednesday to edit out “associate membership” and to read, “We will create an even closer association between Canada and the EU… and work to define by the 2027 EU-Canada Summit the concept of an ever closer association of Canada to the EU, short of full membership itself.”

European politicians expressed great frustration with von der Leyen for not consulting EU member states before making Carney’s and her declaration public. Many EU parliamentarians have spoken out, none so forcibly as German MEP Christine Anderson, whose speech has gone viral in social media. Canadian legacy media did not air this tirade against von der Leyen, but many independent media sources carried Andreson’s warning “CANADA, IT’S A TRAP!”: “She is looking for yet another people whose industry she can wipe out, whose prosperity she can destroy, whose speech she can censor, and whose countries she can flood with even more illegal migrants, thus turning Canada into a living hell.”

Carney sidestepped as best he could the embarrassing rejection of Canada being inducted into the EU as an “associate member” by stating, “The good news is it doesn’t matter about specific names or nomenclature. What matters is the difference that it will make to the lives of Canadians.” So, what impact will this new alliance with the EU have on Canadian economic and trade policies and on Canadians? Without the details there are more questions and answers on the deals already agreed to between Carney and von der Leyen. Canadians need clarity on how much Canadian taxpayers must pay the EU for its membership (an estimate is $6.3 billion annually according to an EU formula for members); its contributions to the EU’s defence of Europe and, specifically, for the Ukraine war effort (billions of dollars are being discussed, beyond the $26 billion Canadian taxpayers have given directly to Ukraine); its involvement in the EU’s Migration and Asylum Pact, obligating countries to accept a quota of the total migrants that come to the EU (legally or otherwise) each year; and, its participation in carbon pricing (internal Canadian government documents reveal $2.8 billion in Canadian exports are exposed to EU carbon-border charges – and Carney indicated he is fine with this, stating on Thursday, “The future of trade does take carbon into account. Carbon is trade.”)

Most concerning about the new Canada-EU agreement is the question of national sovereignty. Carney has made the claim that the arrangement will make Canada “a more independent, more sovereign nation.” But when one considers the friction between current EU member countries and the bureaucracy in Brussels on matters of defence, finance, and especially migration, will EU law and regulations override the law of Canada – as it does in Europe? EU laws are mandated by Brussels and often supersede national agendas of European countries. Consider migration quotas and the riots in Europe, fertilizer regulations and the Dutch farmers, the digital euro and the mandated end of cash, and von der Leyen’s latest musings about instituting an EU tax on personal savings accounts. 

While Carney repeatedly offers reassurances that the EU agreement will protect Canada’s sovereignty, in her address on Thursday morning in Montreal, von der Leyen provided her vision of the path forward. According to the EU president, Canada is about to become closer than ever before to the EU with a partnership that will be forged with greater policy alignment in areas from AI and climate, to energy and security, with close alignment on governance and she states “more work shared by the European Commission and the Canadian government, parliament-to-parliament between our two parliaments, and court-to-court,” and, with a close alignment on each other’s programs.

Given von der Leyen’s vision, clearly, the devil is in the details. Perhaps the Canada-EU Summit will shed some light on what Carney has negotiated with his backroom EU deals. According to recent public opinion polls, most Canadians are supporting the prime minister’s pivot away from the United States to establishing a new alliance with the EU and a strategic partnership with China. In saying that, however, it is overdue for the Carney Liberals to inform Canadians of the costs of their pivot to Brussels and Beijing, the dollars that are expected from Canadian taxpayers and the obligations set out and agreed to in Canada’s new alliances.

Chris George
Columnist

Chris George is an advocate, government relations advisor, and writer/copy editor. As president of a public relations firm established in 1994, Chris provides discreet counsel, tactical advice and management skills to CEOs/Presidents, Boards of Directors and senior executive teams in executing public and government relations campaigns and managing issues. Prior to this PR/GR career, Chris spent seven years on Parliament Hill on staffs of Cabinet Ministers and MPs. He has served in senior campaign positions for electoral and advocacy campaigns at every level of government. Today, Chris resides in Almonte, Ontario where he and his wife manage www.cgacommunications.com. Contact Chris at chrisg.george@gmail.com.

More from Chris George →