Another Trudeau era law in for major changes as Carney refuses to appeal court ruling
Yet another Trudeau era law that was designed to harm Canada’s resource development sector will be coming off the books, at least in part, thanks to a recent ruling by the Alberta Court of Appeal.
The Carney government says it will not appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court of Canada, choosing to amend the legislation instead.
In a 4-1 opinion released on Oct. 9, Albera’s highest court concluded that the changes made to the Impact Assessment Act (IAA) in 2024 did not fix the problems identified by the Supreme Court in 2023.
The biggest constitutional issue with the IAA, according to the Alberta court, is federal interference in provincial jurisdiction. That is an issue that the Trudeau government supposedly tried to remedy in 2024 through its amendments, but the Alberta Court of Appeal found that the amendments did not sufficiently curtail Ottawa’s interference in provincial jurisdiction.
The IAA’s critics rightly point out that the law gives the federal government unconstitutional authority to regulate local projects, largely under the guise of “public interest,” which creates a de facto federal veto over provincial natural resources.
The law was found to be largely unconstitutional in 2023, but the Trudeau government amended it in 2024 rather than scrap it. However, those amendments, according to the law’s critics (and now the Alberta Court of Appeal), did not actually fix the issue, necessitating further changes.
Notably, this case was a reference case, so the Carney government could have appealed the ruling to the Supreme Court and sought to reverse the Alberta court’s decision or at least narrow its impact. By choosing not to do so, the Carney government, which plans to amend the legislation, according to Environment Minister Jule Dabrusin, will have to significantly narrow its scope.
This is the first time the IAA, nicknamed by its critics as the “No More Pipelines Act” because of the burdens and delays it adds to the approval process for major energy and mining projects, will be amended directly by the Carney government.
"*" indicates required fields
Prime Minister Mark Carney has taken stances publicly that at least appear to be friendlier to natural resource development compared to his predecessor, so it will be very interesting to see whether Carney follows through on his pro-resource rhetoric by significantly scaling back the IAA.
The IAA was one of the so-called “nine bad laws” from the Trudeau era that Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has sought to get the federal government to repeal for years. The federal government’s decision not to challenge the Alberta court’s ruling is a major win for Smith.
Smith and Alberta Justice Minister Mickey Amery are already presuming that the Carney government’s amendments will significantly improve the IAA, saying the ruling “will necessitate a major overhaul to the legislation that will result in the elimination of all federal interference in intra-provincial infrastructure projects.”
Whether Smith and Amery will be fully satisfied with the Carney government’s changes remain to be seen, but environmental activists were up in arms about the Carney government’s decision not to appeal the Alberta Court’s ruling.
Ecojustice, for example, argued that the federal government should be trying to assert federal environmental jurisdiction in these areas.
Clearly, if Ecojustice is unhappy with the Carney government’s decision and the Alberta government is on the sidelines cheering, the Carney government’s move will be to the benefit of natural resource development in Canada.
However, the rubber will hit the road when Canadians actually get to see exactly how Carney plans to amend the IAA to make it comply with the Alberta Court of Appeal’s ruling. The IAA will surely get friendlier to resource development, but the question will be how much friendlier.
For the sake of Canada’s economy, let’s hope Carney does the right thing and overhauls the IAA to stop the federal government from meddling in areas of provincial jurisdiction.