Temporary foreign workers program full of problems
The federal Conservatives have made a bold move by calling for an end to the Temporary Foreign Worker (TFW) Program.
At a press conference last Wednesday, immigration critic Michelle Rempel Garner said hopes for young people are getting dashed early. It’s hard to build a good resume when you can’t even get your first job. The downsides to this program are many and the consequences will be felt for years.
“All summer, we heard countless gut punching stories about young Canadians who have put out hundreds of resumes without getting as much as a single call back,” the Calgary MP said.
“One in five students are returning to school this week who looked for a job this summer and didn’t find one, in large part because they’re competing with temporary foreign workers for scarce, entry level jobs,” she said.
The struggle is real. Ottawa has 47,000 unemployed youth, comprising almost one quarter of the 199,300 unemployed youth in Ontario as a whole. The youth unemployment rate is 16 per cent in Ontario, but that’s still better than the 20.3 per cent in Alberta.
Rempel has been driving the point home for days on her X account. She’s been snooping job offers at JobWatchCanada.com and found no shortage of employers making employment available to temporary foreign workers. A short list of jobs she found in Ontario include Mucho Burrito, Ottawa area, $36/hr; Subway, Brampton, $36.10/hr; Canadian Tire, Kingston, $42.78/hr; Domino’s Pizza, Niagara Falls, $36/hr; and Cheese Boutique bakery supervisor, Toronto, $36/hr.
Alas, these rates make journalism look like an entry-level profession. However, not all is as bright as it seems.
A 2024 United Nations report said the TFW program “serves as a breeding ground for contemporary forms of slavery, as it institutionalizes asymmetries of power that favour employers and prevent workers from exercising their rights.”
"*" indicates required fields
The report said many workers borrow significant sums to pay recruiters or secure spots in the program, leading to debt bondage where they must tolerate abuse to repay loans and support families back home. Employers sometimes confiscate documents, further limiting workers’ mobility.
Another question is what happens when a TFW’s visa expires? Sometimes they can find legal ways to remain in Canada, but not always. Decades of evidence shows they might stay anyway.
An old study from 2002 found that 64,000 people overstayed work, student, or visitor visas, and 36,000 failed refugee claimants were never deported. An estimated 76,000 non-status people worked in Ontario construction in 2003.
Current estimates of undocumented migrants in Canada range as high as 500,000, with a significant portion being TFW’s. Who knows how many food service workers brought in for $35/hr are now getting paid just $12 under the table? When it’s either that or get reported and deported, what do you do?
TFWs don’t form a large part of the workforce, but their numbers have grown substantially. A recent Bloomberg article pointed out that Tim Horton’s has 1,131 per cent more temporary foreign workers than it did just four years ago–in other words, 12 times as much as in 2021. The article title said it all: “Cheap Foreign Labor Soars in Canada as Young Workers Are Left Jobless.”
Even Statistics Canada can’t keep up. A StatsCan analysis released in November 2024 told us that TFWs numbered 356,000 in 2011 and 844,800 in 2021. But that same study suggested 1.5 million non-permanent residents were likely working in 2024.
Federal Liberal efforts to curb the TFW problems have failed. In 2022, they made efforts to address undue exploitation, but they have been hard to enforce and made little impact. More recently, the Carney government promised to cap TFWs at 82,000, yet they already issued 105,000 new permits in the first six months of the year.
The Conservative announcement has had some detractors. The reflex accusation of “racism” was tossed around by at least one national news guest. Also, the Canadian Federation of Independent Business said some of its members have relied on the program as a last resort after being unable to find Canadians willing to work.
More surprisingly, the Conservative announcement found an ally in British Columbia NDP Premier David Eby. He told reporters the TFW program should “be cancelled or significantly reformed,” given the “very high unemployment rates” among young people.
“We can’t have an immigration system that outpaces our ability to build schools, and housing, and we can’t have an immigration program that results in high unemployment,” Eby said.
Eby is right. A suspension of the TFW program would probably do more help than harm to a country experiencing too many growing pains.