Canada & Argentina, on two very different fiscal & economic paths
Contrasting the details of this week’s Canadian federal budget with last week’s results of Argentina’s midterm elections is a comparison that Canadians would be wise to take note of: Canada and Argentina are on two very different fiscal and economic paths. Those divergent paths have been intentionally chosen by the countries’ leaders – global banker Mark Carney and libertarian economist Javier Milei. The leaders’ opposite approach to the challenges the countries’ face may prove to be an instructive case study – one that will have lasting impact on the countries’ respective economic development and peoples’ future prosperity.
With the tabling of the federal budget, Canadians learned that the Carney government is spending money at a greater rate than the Trudeau Liberals did during Canada’s Lost Decade. Imagine: the total debt of the projected deficits over the next five years is more than double what Justin Trudeau would have spent (Carney’s tally at $321.7 billion vs. Trudeau’s at $154.4 billion). Finance minister Francois-Philippe Champagne delivered the largest deficit in Canadian history outside of the pandemic years. It was the tenth consecutive deficit and the Liberals provided no plan to balance the budget.
The nation’s spreadsheet revealed that PM Carney’s fiscal approach is to spend, print money – and spend some more. This fiscal year the government is spending $581 billion. The $78.3 billion deficit this year has increased more than 50 per cent over last year’s deficit. The government’s net debt is now a $1.48 trillion hole that is forecasted to deepen by 21 per cent in the next five years. Interest payments to service that federal debt amount to more than one billion dollars a week and, in 2030, with the Carney fiscal plan in place, Canadians will be paying bankers $1.5 billion per week (taxpayers’ dollars that could go otherwise to health care, programs and services, and provincial transfer payments).
Two budget details that were not widely reported in the government-subsidized legacy media are the forecasted economic growth and the raised debt ceiling. The Carney government projects a sagging economy for the next five years (1.1 per cent real GDP growth in 2026 and 1.2 per cent next year). This dismal outlook does not reflect the PM’s boasts of having the strongest economy in the G-7 but rather the OECD projections of Canada being one of the weakest economies in the world through 2030, to 2060. Secondly, independent news source Blacklock’s Reporter revealed that the department of finance will be hiking its borrowing limit by 20 percent to an unprecedented $2.54 trillion. This will be the third time in four years that the Liberals have raised the national debt ceiling, to give them more credit in order to spend more.
A centre piece of the budget is the Carney government’s “climate competitiveness strategy” which is set to usher in “a stronger industrial carbon pricing system.” Not surprisingly, Mark Carney has continued with the Trudeau government approach to closely align Canada’s economic growth strategies to global climate change objectives of the United Nations (UN), the World Economic Forum (WEF), and their 2030 Agenda net zero agendas. Canada is adhering to a global industrial strategy that focuses on transitioning energy use away from fossil fuels to renewables; it is an anti-oil and gas strategy. As it is described in the budget, Carney’s “new climate plan” will increase the industrial carbon tax beyond 2030 and will be targeting large emitters to pay more: Canadian energy and natural resource companies, manufacturers, and infrastructure projects. This carbon-tax-climate-strategy is the very approach that has seen too many natural resource projects abandoned since 2015; one estimate is that Canada has seen $670 billion in cancelled oil, gas, liquefied natural gas (LNG), and pipeline projects during Canada’s Lost Decade.
In framing Canadians’ expectations prior to the budget delivery, PM Carney told an audience of university students that young people would need to sacrifice, and Bank of Canada governor Tiff Macklem observed that Canadians must accept a lower standard of living if things did not change. Their messages are sobering given Canada’s standard of living has slipped considerably against our American neighbours to the south in the last five years. As it is now, Ontario residents’ standard of living is similar to the worst state in the U.S. – Mississippi. And to address this sad situation, the Carney Liberals propose to regulate industry more, and to set a fiscal path that spends more, at rates that Jason Jacques, Canada’s interim Parliamentary Budget Officer, described as “stupefying”, “shocking”, and “unsustainable.” The financial markets seemingly did not receive the budget well as the Canadian dollar has sunk to a seven-month low. This is Canada’s chosen path forward and Canadians are to sacrifice and expect less for now so that the Liberals can spend more, tax industries more, and guide our underperforming economy with a promise of some better time beyond 2030.
"*" indicates required fields
Canada’s economic trajectory would be rather glum if it was not for the knowledge that there is another path forward. This path is being blazed by Javier Milei, an “irascible libertarian”, self-described “anarcho-capitalist”, and he is the very antithesis of Mark Carney (who has been dubbed in international circles as the quintessential “Davos Man”). In the two years he has been in office, Milei has turned Argentina into a libertarian laboratory where there has been a striking economic turnaround.
On the news of President Milei’s decisive electoral success in the country’s midterm elections, a feature in The Economist suggests the Argentinian leader’s fiscal and economic approach should be modelled, “Javier Milei’s chance to transform Argentina and teach the world.” Milei is being credited with turning the fortunes of the country around after decades of socialist governments that were big spending, printing money, empowering bureaucracy and central planning that resulted in throttling and driving away industry and investment. In late 2023, Argentina’s poverty rate was above 40 per cent, its economic growth rate was negative 1.6 per cent, and inflation 289 per cent.
With the country in shambles and its citizens hopeless, Milei took charge. He took his signature “chainsaw” approach to public spending and the bureaucracy. Milei eliminated 10 of 18 government ministries, capped the salaries of top bureaucrats and held public sector pensions, fired 34,000 (16 per cent) of government employees, and cut spending by 30 percent. These brutal cost-cutting measures resulted in budgetary surpluses the first month of his term of office – and for every month since.
Though Argentinians struggle and do not have it easy, they returned Milei’s political party with a “landslide victory” in the midterm elections, providing “the madman” with even more political authority to continue with his disciplined austerity to refashion the country’s economy. On news of the win, the Argentine peso jumped 10 per cent and the local stock market shot up by over 20 per cent.
Milei is ambitious in moving forward with reforming the country’s monetary policy, tax system, labour laws, and pensions. In the first two years of his government, the libertarian ensured Argentina became more attractive for new investment and enterprise. As he explained in an interview with The Economist, Milei’s contempt for big government is “infinite” and he is guided by the imperative, “Anything I can do to remove the interference of the state, I’m going to do.”
With Milei’s direction, the country has unharnessed its rich oil fields and, last year Argentina exported more energy than it imported for the first time in 14 years. It is now on track to yield one million barrels of oil per day by 2030. This would bring in more than $30 billion into Argentina annually and create a half a million jobs in the next five years. Milei refers to the country’s shale oil reserves as a “panacea” and is encouraging greater energy exports by funding big infrastructure investments in new pipelines that will take oil to tidewater and to a new deep water port. The near-term vision is to develop exports of LNG to the Asian market.
Unlike Mark Carney and his intent to steer Canada into the orbit of Davos, Geneva, and Brussels, Javier Milei is a vocal anti-globalist. He has railed against the WEF and Davos crowd stating at a WEF assembly, “It is our moral duty and responsibility to dismantle the ideological edifice of sickly wokeism.” Argentina has left the World Health Organization citing “deep differences regarding health management especially during the pandemic” and the fact that Argentina would never “allow an international body to interfere in our sovereignty.” Milei is also considering pulling out of the Paris Agreement and the UN’s 2030 Agenda and its net-zero initiatives. Last month, at the UN assembly, Milei slammed the organization and its agencies as a “supranational model of governance led by international bureaucrats, who seek to impose a particular way of life on the citizens of the world.” Clearly, under Milei’s watch, Argentina will not become another of the globalists’ post-national states.
Last word for now goes to the libertarian maverick, who is proving to be a clarion for disciplined fiscal management, free enterprise, and strategic natural resource development. Milei observed before the UN assembly, “The entire world appears to be stuck in the comfort of the present, ignoring the consequences this may bring in the future. As discomfort costs votes and power to those who embrace it, leaders prefer to do everything in their power to preserve the inherited status quo – even at the expense of future consequences. They set the future ablaze to keep the present warm.”
Milei then offered this counsel against misguided socialist fiscal and economic policies, “It is my duty to warn against this evil because in Argentina we have experienced it to its natural conclusion. We have reached the end of the comfortable path that leads to ignoring the future. We come from a future that, for you, has not yet arrived. And I want to tell you that you still have time to avoid it.”